Fork the consciousness, or download the project and create your own.

Which Animals Are Conscious. Feinberg and Mallatt Mapped Across 560 Million Years

Todd E. Feinberg and Jon M. Mallatt argue that consciousness began three separate times, in three lineages that had already parted company, inside a single window of about forty million years. This console maps that claim. Every clade below carries their verdict, the brain structure they name for it, and a source you can check.

Origins Console From Biology to Code
LOADINGStatus
presentEpoch
0Ruled in
0Clades shown
–Verdict
present day
Drag pan time Pinch or wheel zoom

Six features across clades

clade 1 2 3 4 5 6
Sponges
Cnidarians•
Roundworms•
Protochordates•
Snails and slugs•?
Decapod crustaceans••?••?
Early vertebrates••••••
Arthropods••?•••
Cephalopods••?••?
Ray finned fish••••••
Amphibians••••••
Reptiles••••••
Mammals••••••
Birds••••••
  1. 1 Many neuron types
  2. 2 Hierarchical processing
  3. 3 Dual hierarchy
  4. 4 Isomorphic mapping
  5. 5 Reentrant connections
  6. 6 Oscillatory binding

Present, absent and unknown are three states, never two. A question mark means the source does not say, which is not the same as no. The full feature list is on the architecture page.

Event log

Every clade in the console, with the verdict and its source
CladeVerdictKindStructureFirst evidence
Porifera ruled out – none named 600 Maapproximate
Sponges have no neurons and no nervous system of any kind. They carry many of the genes that build synapses in other animals, which is why they matter here. The genetic toolkit came first and did not produce a nervous system on its own. Feinberg and Mallatt 2013.
Jellyfish, corals, sea anemones ruled out – Nerve net 580 Maapproximate
A nerve net conducts signals in every direction without a centre that integrates them. Feinberg and Mallatt treat this as the clearest case of neurons without the organisation their account requires. Feinberg and Mallatt 2013.
Nematoda ruled out – Nerve ring 540 Maapproximate
The entire wiring diagram of this animal has been known since 1986, and it contains no structure that maps the world onto the nervous system in the way the account requires. A complete connectome is not by itself a conscious one. Feinberg and Mallatt 2013.
Lancelets and sea squirts ruled out – none named 530 Maapproximate
These are our own closest invertebrate relatives and Feinberg and Mallatt exclude them by name. They sit immediately below the vertebrates on the tree, which is what makes the exclusion a real claim rather than an easy one. Feinberg and Mallatt 2013.
Gastropoda ruled out – Paired ganglia 530 Maapproximate
Most molluscs are excluded even though one branch of the same phylum, the cephalopods, is included. The line is drawn by neural organisation and not by ancestry, which is the whole point of the account. Feinberg and Mallatt 2020.
Crabs, lobsters, prawns contested affective Mushroom bodies 440 Maapproximate
Jonathan Birch's review for the UK government found enough evidence of pain in decapods to bring them under the Animal Welfare Sentience Act in 2022. The evidence is behavioural and pharmacological rather than anatomical, which is exactly the kind Feinberg and Mallatt treat as insufficient on its own. Their own verdict is hedged: the 2016 book counts arthropods, including insects and probably crustaceans, as meeting much of their criteria. That "probably" is why this page marks decapods contested and not ruled in. Feinberg and Mallatt 2016, The Ancient Origins of Consciousness, publisher description (insects and probably crustaceans). Birch et al. 2021, LSE review of the evidence of sentience.
Lampreys and their Cambrian ancestors ruled in image based, affective Optic tectum 520 Ma
This is the origin claim the whole account rests on. Consciousness did not wait for a cerebral cortex. It appeared in a midbrain structure that stacks sensory maps in register, and every vertebrate since has inherited it. Feinberg and Mallatt 2013. Feinberg and Mallatt 2020.
Insects and their relatives ruled in image based Lamina, medulla, lobula 520 Ma
A second origin, on a lineage that split from ours before either had a brain. The insect visual hierarchy solves the same problem as the vertebrate one with entirely different parts, which is the strongest evidence in the account that the organisation matters and the specific tissue does not. Feinberg and Mallatt 2020.
Octopus, cuttlefish, squid ruled in image based Vertical lobe 520 Ma
A third origin, and the one that most resembles ours by accident. The vertical lobe fans 1.8 million input fibres out onto 25 million interneurons and back in onto 65,000 outputs. The insect mushroom body and the mammalian cerebellum use the same three layer fan out fan in plan, arrived at three separate times. Feinberg and Mallatt 2020. Bidel et al. 2023, connectomics of the Octopus vulgaris vertical lobe, eLife.
Actinopterygii ruled in image based, affective Optic tectum 420 Maapproximate
In fish the optic tectum is the main visual brain and the forebrain is small. If the account is right, this is the clearest living case of consciousness running on the structure that carried it first. Feinberg and Mallatt 2013.
Frogs, salamanders, axolotls ruled in image based, affective Optic tectum 350 Maapproximate
The axolotl keeps its larval form for life and regrows brain tissue after injury. It is the same tectal plan as every other vertebrate, in an animal that rebuilds it. Feinberg and Mallatt 2016, The Ancient Origins of Consciousness, MIT Press.
Turtles, lizards, snakes, crocodilians ruled in image based, affective Optic tectum 310 Maapproximate
Reptiles built a second forebrain sensory area that is not our cortex and did not descend from a shared one. Two solutions, one function, on top of the same inherited tectum. Feinberg and Mallatt 2016, The Ancient Origins of Consciousness, MIT Press.
Cats, dogs, horses, bats, humans ruled in image based, affective Superior colliculus 180 Maapproximate
The cortex is the newest part of this story and not the origin of it. The optic tectum is still in every mammal head under a different name, doing the same job it did 520 million years ago. Feinberg and Mallatt 2020.
Owls, hummingbirds, corvids ruled in image based, affective Optic tectum 110 Maapproximate
The barn owl tectum holds a map of auditory space aligned with the visual map, built from arrival time differences between the two ears. It is the textbook demonstration that this structure registers senses onto one another, and it sits in a brain with no cortical layers at all. Feinberg and Mallatt 2020.
Birch et al. 2021, confidence that each group meets each criterion. VH very high, H high, M medium, L low, VL very low. Low means thin evidence, not a failure.
Group12345678H or VH
Octopods OctopodaVHVHHHMVHVHH7 of 8
Cuttlefish SepiidaHVHHLMMVHL4 of 8
Other coleoids, squid all ordersHVHHLMLHL4 of 8
Nautiloids NautilidaHLLLLLMVL1 of 8
True crabs BrachyuraHVHLVHLVHHVL5 of 8
Anomuran crabs AnomuraHVHLLMHLVL3 of 8
Lobsters and crayfish AstacideaHVHLVHLLMVL3 of 8
Spiny lobsters AchelataHVHLLLLMVL2 of 8
Caridean shrimps CarideaHVHLMLMLVL2 of 8
Penaeid shrimps PenaeidaeHLLMLLLVL1 of 8
  1. Has receptors that respond to harmful stimuli
  2. Has brain regions that combine input from different senses
  3. Has nerve pathways from those receptors to those brain regions
  4. Its response to harm changes under painkillers, anaesthetics or its own opioid-like signals
  5. Weighs a threat against a reward, and the balance can change
  6. Protects an injured body part in a flexible way, for example by guarding or rubbing it
  7. Learns to link harm with a neutral cue, or learns new ways to avoid harm
  8. Shows that it values a painkiller when injured, for example by learning to seek it

What the console shows and does not show

It shows one research programme’s verdict, not a consensus. Feinberg and Mallatt argue that three lineages crossed into consciousness independently. Vertebrates did it with the optic tectum, a midbrain structure that stacks sensory maps in register. Arthropods did it with a layered visual hierarchy and a central complex behind a compound eye. Cephalopods did it with a vertical lobe and a camera eye that evolved with no help from ours. None of the three inherited the solution from a common ancestor that had it.

A short film follows the vertebrate origin, from the Cambrian sea and the optic tectum of the first jawless fish to the insects and octopuses that may have found their own way. Watch the film, Did awareness begin 520 million years ago, on YouTube.

The tree view shows that claim as a shape. The branching order comes from the Open Tree of Life, a synthesis of published phylogenies released under a CC0 licence, with one living species standing for each clade. Each of the three origins sits on its own branch, and the branches that split before them stay grey. A clay branch inherits an origin from its ancestor, which is why the mammals and the birds are clay without an origin of their own. The tree shows order only. Its branch lengths are not times, because the oldest fossil records include disputed ones, so each clade carries its own dated first evidence instead. Reptiles are not one branch in the tree, because birds sit inside them, so the turtle stands for the reptiles here.

The criteria panel lets you disagree with the verdicts. Switch on any of the six features and the tree judges every clade on those features alone, from the same present, absent and unknown records as the feature grid. Require only dual hierarchy and the six vertebrate clades pass, while the arthropods and the cephalopods become unknown, because the sources do not say whether they have it. Require all six and the result is the same. Feinberg and Mallatt rule in eight clades. The difference is between their full argument and this site’s six-feature condensation of it, and the panel shows exactly which records make it.

The “Whose criteria” buttons judge the same clades by two other research programmes. Jonathan Birch, Charlotte Burn, Alexandra Schnell, Heather Browning and Andrew Crump reviewed more than 300 studies for the UK government in 2021 against eight criteria of sentience, from pain receptors to an injured animal seeking a painkiller. They graded the octopods very strong evidence, the true crabs strong, and the squid, the cuttlefish, the anomuran crabs and the lobsters substantial. Their review covers only cephalopods and decapods, so every other clade is drawn hollow, not grey. The table under the console gives their confidence for each group and criterion. The grades are their own scheme applied to that table. For caridean shrimps the report’s foreword says substantial, but the table gives two criteria at high confidence, which the scheme grades as some evidence, and the console follows the table.

Simona Ginsburg and Eva Jablonka use one marker instead, unlimited associative learning: an animal that learns from new cues made of several features, chains one association onto another and bridges a gap in time. In the 2020 primer by Birch, Ginsburg and Jablonka they conjecture that most vertebrates, some arthropods and the coleoid cephalopods have it, and that snails and roundworms do not, a verdict they call very tentative. That gives the same three origins as Feinberg and Mallatt, reached by a different route. They do not name the crustaceans, so the decapods stay hollow.

The animals in the specimen view are silhouettes from PhyloPic, the curated database of organism silhouettes, recoloured to the console palette. The shape of an animal is not a claim on this page. The only labelled parts are the brain structures Feinberg and Mallatt name, and those labels are claims to check against the cited sources. Silhouette authors and licence terms are listed at the end of this page.

The dates come from two places and the console labels which. The three origins carry Feinberg and Mallatt’s own figure of 560 to 520 million years ago. Everything else is a rounded first appearance estimate, present so the chart has an order, and it is marked approximate in the table. No approximate date is ever presented as their claim.

The six features are this site’s condensation, not a quotation. Feinberg and Mallatt group their special neurobiological features differently in different papers. Two main requirements in 2013, about eight categories in their 2019 table, about twelve sub-items in 2020. The six used here are the ones that map onto the architecture this project builds, and they are listed in full on the technical architecture page. Where a source does not state whether a clade has a feature, the console shows a question mark. A source that is silent is not a source that says no.

Why this belongs on this site

Because it is the strongest argument against what this project is trying to do, and it deserves to be shown properly rather than summarised away.

Feinberg and Mallatt hold that sentience is an evolved biological specialisation requiring living physiological structure, homeostatic regulation and real metabolic stakes. That is a direct challenge to substrate independence, which is the premise of functionalist emergentism and of this whole site. Their position is set out in full in Jon Mallatt and Todd Feinberg on animal-only sentience.

The interesting part is what their own evidence does to their conclusion. Three lineages that had already split reached the same functional organisation with different tissue, different eyes and different brains. The octopus vertical lobe fans 1.8 million input fibres out onto 25 million interneurons and back in onto 65,000 outputs. The insect mushroom body and the mammalian cerebellum use that same three layer fan out fan in plan, arrived at separately. If the organisation is what recurs and the tissue is what varies, then the evidence assembled to show that biology is necessary is also the best catalogue we have of how little the specific biology seems to make a difference.

That is the open question, and this console exists so you can look at the evidence and disagree with either side of it.

Silhouette credits

The animal silhouettes come from PhyloPic, phylopic.org, and are recoloured from black to the console palette. Each author and licence follows. Public Domain and CC0 images carry no attribution requirement; CC BY images carry an attribution requirement; the two CC BY-SA images are shared here under the same terms.

Silhouette Author Licence
Amphimedon queenslandica seung9park CC0 1.0
Aurelia aurita Lodewijk van Walraven CC0 1.0
Caenorhabditis elegans Gareth Monger CC BY 3.0
Amphioxidae Noah Schlottman CC BY-SA 3.0
Helix aspersa Gareth Monger CC BY 3.0
Dicranodromia mahieuxii T. Michael Keesey Public Domain Mark 1.0
Haikouichthys ercaicunensis T. Michael Keesey CC BY-SA 3.0
Diptera T. Michael Keesey Public Domain Mark 1.0
Octopus vulgaris Margot Michaud CC0 1.0
Danio rerio Chuanxin Yu CC0 1.0
Ambystoma mexicanum Jake Warner CC0 1.0
Natator depressus T. Michael Keesey Public Domain Mark 1.0
Caracal aurata Roderic Page Public Domain Mark 1.0
Phodilus badius T. Michael Keesey Public Domain Mark 1.0

Tell me, are you conscious?

The question this project asks of any substrate, printed on the animals it also applies to. Every order funds the research.

All merch