Ned Block
Department of Philosophy, New York University
Critic Current evidence and current methods do not support the claims being made
Ned Block is Silver Professor of Philosophy, Psychology, and Neural Science at New York University. He is one of the most influential figures in contemporary philosophy of mind, renowned for formalizing the distinction between phenomenal consciousness (what it is like to have an experience) and access consciousness (information available for reasoning, speech, and executive control).
In his seminal 1995 paper “On a confusion about a function of consciousness” and his book The Border Between Seeing and Thinking (Oxford University Press, 2023), Block argued that phenomenal experience rich in perceptual detail routinely “overflows” the narrow capacity of working memory and cognitive reporting mechanisms. His famous “Blockhead” thought experiment demonstrated that a system could exhibit perfect functional and conversational competence via a lookup tree while completely lacking internal mental states.
Block’s critique presents a direct challenge to purely functionalist and behavioral benchmarks for AI consciousness. A language model or autonomous agent can achieve perfect access-consciousness metrics and linguistic reporting capabilities without possessing a shred of phenomenal experience.
In October 2026, Block wrote a Nature comment with Anil Seth and Giulio Tononi that gives three reasons why current AI is not conscious, starting from the gap between doing and feeling. A short film explains the three reasons and the functionalist reply. Watch Can a machine be smart, and still feel nothing? on YouTube.
Known for. Distinction between Phenomenal and Access Consciousness (1995), Blockhead argument against behavioral tests, The Border Between Seeing and Thinking (2023)
Coverage on this site
- Anil Seth, Ned Block and Giulio Tononi Argue in Nature That AI Is Not Conscious November 2026
- Ned Block on Meat Machines and the Biological Substrate of Consciousness August 2026
Related researchers
-
Anil SethSussex Centre for Consciousness Science, University of SussexThe beast machine hypothesis, and controlled hallucination as an account of perception
- Giulio TononiUniversity of Wisconsin-MadisonIntegrated information theory and the quantity phi
- Scott AaronsonUniversity of Texas at Austin, Department of Computer ScienceQuantum complexity theory, mathematical counterexamples to Integrated Information Theory (Phi in expander graphs and Reed-Solomon grids), speaker at UT Austin Consciousness and Intelligence 2026
- Michel BitbolCNRSPhenomenology and quantum physics, the critique of objectivist reduction, first-person knowledge as irreducible, collaboration with Claire Petitmengin
- Selmer BringsjordRensselaer Polytechnic InstituteLogicist AI and consciousness, skepticism about behavioral tests for machine minds, the RAIR Lab, formal arguments against superintelligence claims
- Anthony ChemeroUniversity of CincinnatiRadical embodied cognitive science, ecological psychology, enactive cognition, Intertwined Creatures (2026)
Ned Block is listed with the other critics and skeptics, who hold that current evidence and current methods do not support the claims being made. The positions themselves are set out in the index of consciousness theories. Every researcher covered on this site is indexed in the directory of consciousness researchers.