Giulio Tononi
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Integrated information Consciousness is intrinsic causal power, measured as integrated information
Position on AI consciousness
Tononi holds that most current AI is ruled out, because feedforward networks have near zero phi however capable they are, and that a simulation of a conscious brain would not be conscious, since the simulation's causal structure is the computer's rather than the thing simulated.
Giulio Tononi built the only major theory of consciousness that works backwards. Rather than examining brains and inferring what consciousness is, integrated information theory starts from properties experience is taken to have, that it exists, is structured, specific, unified and definite, and derives what a physical substrate must be like to have them. The quantity phi measures the result, how much a system’s cause and effect structure exceeds the sum of its parts.
The derivation has consequences most people find surprising and Tononi accepts. Feedforward networks have near zero phi however capable they are, so most current AI is ruled out. A simulation of a conscious brain would not be conscious, because the simulation’s causal structure is that of the computer rather than of the thing simulated. And simple systems with the right connectivity can score very high, which Scott Aaronson turned into the sharpest objection the theory has faced.
Tononi’s response to that objection is the most revealing thing about the theory. He did not dispute the mathematics. He accepted that the system in question is conscious and argued that our intuitions about which things have experience are unreliable. That is internally consistent, and it detaches the theory from independent checks, which is why phi remains uncomputable in practice and contested in principle.
In October 2026, Tononi wrote a Nature comment with Anil Seth and Ned Block that gives three reasons why current AI is not conscious. The third is the IIT requirement for reentrant loops, which feedforward layers lack. A short film explains the three reasons and the functionalist reply. Watch Can a machine be smart, and still feel nothing? on YouTube.
Known for. Integrated information theory and the quantity phi
Coverage on this site
Research Papers and Preprints
- Anil Seth, Ned Block and Giulio Tononi Argue in Nature That AI Is Not Conscious November 2026
- Tononi, Grasso, and Hendren on QStr, a New Method for Measuring Intrinsic Structure in Any Substrate August 2026
- Scott Aaronson and the Expander Graph Objection to Integrated Information Theory August 2026
- The Tononi Lab and the Phi Structure at the Centre of IIT 4.0 August 2026
- Melanie Boly and the Neural Correlates of Pure Presence Under IIT August 2026
- Giulio Tononi IIT Field Formulation Continuous AI Architectures 2026 August 2026
- Integrated Information Theory Field Formulations and Resolving IIT 4.0 Misunderstandings July 2026
- Tononi and Boly's IIT 4.0 Why Consciousness Is Identical to Cause-Effect Structure June 2026
- When IIT and GNW Were Put to the Test What the Cogitate Consortium Found April 2026
- Measuring Consciousness in Machines The Brock University and IONS Research on IIT Equations April 2026
- Differentiating AI and Consciousness and IIT Perspectives for TCAI January 2025
Keynotes and Event Talks
Articles and Commentary
- Pantheon Uploaded Intelligence and the Neuroscience of Mind Uploading October 2026
- Before the Frameworks, There Were Shows How Classic Television Invented the AI Consciousness Problem March 2026
Related researchers
-
Anil SethSussex Centre for Consciousness Science, University of SussexThe beast machine hypothesis, and controlled hallucination as an account of perception
- Ned BlockDepartment of Philosophy, New York UniversityDistinction between Phenomenal and Access Consciousness (1995), Blockhead argument against behavioral tests, The Border Between Seeing and Thinking (2023)
- Derek ParfitAll Souls College, University of Oxford. 1942 to 2017Reasons and Persons (1984), the branch-line case, and the claim that personal identity is not what matters
-
David ChalmersNew York University. Co-director, Center for Mind, Brain and ConsciousnessNaming the hard problem of consciousness, and the philosophical zombie argument
-
Mark SolmsUniversity of Cape TownNeuropsychoanalysis, and the brainstem account of affective consciousness
- Karl FristonUniversity College London. Chief Scientist, VERSES AIThe free energy principle and active inference
Giulio Tononi is listed with the other integrated information theorists, who hold that consciousness is intrinsic causal power, measured as integrated information. The theory family behind that position is set out in the index of consciousness theories. Every researcher covered on this site is indexed in the directory of consciousness researchers.