Mark Solms
University of Cape Town
Biological naturalist Consciousness requires living metabolic hardware
Mark Solms argues that consciousness science has been looking in the wrong place. The cortex, where most of the search has happened, elaborates and organises experience. It does not generate it. The source is the brainstem, specifically the ascending arousal systems and the homeostatic drives that give outcomes stakes for an organism before any of them are thought about.
The evidence he leans on is clinical and hard to dismiss. Children born without a cortex are not unconscious. They show affect, preference and engagement. If cortical processing were the origin of experience, that should not be possible.
For artificial systems this relocates the criterion entirely. Cognitive benchmarks, language understanding and self modelling all evaluate the wrong tier. The test is whether a system has states with genuine valence that regulate its behaviour, rather than learned regularities that produce affect consistent outputs. In October 2026, Solms and colleagues tested that requirement directly in the multi-need AffectWorld simulation, “Two Routes to Interoceptive Prioritisation” (arXiv:2610.18617), examined in our analysis of preference reweighting and interoceptive precision. That is a harder thing to build and a more specific thing to look for, and it is the tier this project’s Affective Core targets.
Known for. Neuropsychoanalysis, and the brainstem account of affective consciousness
Coverage on this site
Research Papers and Preprints
- Mark Solms and Ryan Smith Test Two Routes to Interoceptive Prioritisation October 2026
- Dreaming and Consciousness From David Foulkes to World Models September 2026
- Mark Solms Inferring Affective Consciousness in an Artificial Agent JCS 2026 August 2026
- The Spinning Wheel Theory and the Consciousness Risk Rubric. Hulme and Griffiths at AISB 2026 July 2026
Articles and Commentary
Related researchers
- Ryan SmithLaureate Institute for Brain Research. University of TulsaComputational psychiatry and active inference models of emotional awareness, interoceptive inference, hierarchical models of conscious access and affect
- St John GrimblyDepartment of Computer Science, University of Cape TownAffectWorld multi-need active inference environment, two routes to interoceptive prioritisation (preference reweighting and likelihood precision)
- Benjamin RosmanSchool of Computer Science and Applied Mathematics, University of the WitwatersrandReinforcement learning and decision-making in multi-need agents, skill composition, active inference homeostatic prioritisation
- Jonathan ShockDepartment of Mathematics and Applied Mathematics, University of Cape TownMathematical physics and computational neuroscience of active inference, multi-need homeostatic agency, neural dynamics
- Karl FristonUniversity College London. Chief Scientist, VERSES AIThe free energy principle and active inference
- Derek ParfitAll Souls College, University of Oxford. 1942 to 2017Reasons and Persons (1984), the branch-line case, and the claim that personal identity is not what matters
Mark Solms is listed with the other biological naturalists, who hold that consciousness requires living metabolic hardware. The theory family behind that position is set out in the index of consciousness theories. Every researcher covered on this site is indexed in the directory of consciousness researchers.